Constructive Dismissal

What is constructive dismissal?

Constructive dismissal (also called constructive termination or constructive discharge) occurs when an employee resigns because the employer has made working conditions so intolerable that the employee has no reasonable choice but to leave. Although the employee technically resigns, the law treats it as an involuntary termination initiated by the employer.

Key elements

Fundamental breach by employer:

• Serious violation of employment contract
• Unilateral changes to essential terms
• Creating hostile work environment
• Breach of implied duty of trust and confidence

Intolerable conditions:

• Reasonable person would feel compelled to resign
• Continuation of employment becomes unreasonable
• No viable alternative but to leave
• Pattern of behavior or single serious incident

Lack of consent:

• Employee did not agree to changes
• Objected to treatment
• Did not acquiesce to conditions
• Resignation not voluntary

Causal connection:

• Resignation directly due to employer's conduct
• Clear link between breach and resignation
• Resignation reasonably soon after breach
• Employee communicated reasons

Common scenarios leading to constructive dismissal claims

Unilateral changes to employment terms:

• Significant reduction in salary without agreement
• Demotion or removal of responsibilities
• Forced relocation to different city/country
• Substantial reduction in working hours
• Change from permanent to casual status
• Removal of agreed benefits

Harassment and hostile environment:

• Bullying, intimidation, or threats
• Sexual harassment
• Discrimination based on protected characteristics
• Verbal abuse or humiliation
• Retaliation for complaints
• Creating environment of fear

Breach of contract:

• Non-payment or late payment of wages
• Failure to provide agreed benefits
• Breach of health and safety obligations
• Denial of leave entitlements
• Forcing illegal activities

Undermining and isolation:

• Systematic criticism and fault-finding
• Exclusion from meetings or communications
• Removal of job responsibilities
• Public humiliation
• Impossible performance targets
• Setting up to fail

Failure to address complaints:

• Ignoring serious grievances
• Not investigating workplace issues
• Allowing harassment to continue
• Inaction on health and safety concerns
• Dismissing legitimate complaints

Constructive dismissal across APAC

Singapore:

• Concept recognized in employment law
• Employee can claim wrongful dismissal
• Must prove employer's breach
• Ministry of Manpower may mediate
• Employment Claims Tribunals handle disputes
• Remedies include compensation

Australia:

• "Constructive dismissal" terminology used
• Can claim unfair dismissal
• Fair Work Commission jurisdiction
• Must demonstrate forced resignation
• Strong protections and remedies
• Significant case law

Hong Kong:

• "Constructive dismissal" recognized
• Employee entitled to termination payments
• Can claim unreasonable variation of contract
• Labour Tribunal jurisdiction
• Must resign in response to employer conduct
• Severance and long service payment rights

Japan:

• Concept exists though less formalized
• Difficult to prove in court
• Strong emphasis on employer obligation
• Power harassment (パワハラ) recognition
• Labor tribunal or court route
• Cultural context important

India:

• Industrial Disputes Act covers unfair practices
• Labor courts recognize forced resignation
• "Change in service conditions" concept
• Must prove coercion or intolerable conditions
• Remedies include reinstatement or compensation
• Strong worker protections in principle

Malaysia:

• Constructive dismissal claims recognized
• Industrial Relations Act provides recourse
• Industrial Court jurisdiction
• Must prove employer's breach
• Remedies available if proven
• Growing case law

Other APAC countries:

• Most recognize some form of forced resignation concept
• Varying levels of protection and remedies
• Proof requirements differ
• Cultural and legal frameworks vary
• Some countries have limited formal processes

Proving constructive dismissal

Burden of proof:

• Employee must demonstrate employer's breach
• Clear, convincing evidence required
• Timeline of events important
• Witness testimony helpful
• Documentary evidence crucial

Key evidence:

• Employment contract showing original terms
• Written communications (emails, letters, messages)
• Documentation of complaints made
• Witness statements
• Medical records (if stress-related)
• Performance reviews showing changes
• Policy documents
• Timeline of events

Documentation requirements:

• Contemporary records most valuable
• Specific examples with dates
• Evidence of objection to changes
• Resignation letter citing reasons
• Communication trail showing attempts to resolve

Common challenges:

• Proving intolerable conditions
• Demonstrating causal link
• Timing of resignation
• Acquiescence vs. acceptance
• Subjective vs. objective standards

Employee responsibilities in constructive dismissal situations

Before resigning:

• Raise grievance formally
• Document all issues in writing
• Allow employer opportunity to remedy
• Keep detailed records
• Seek internal resolution where possible
• Consider less drastic alternatives

When resigning:

• Resign promptly after breach (don't delay unreasonably)
• State clearly reason for resignation
• Reference specific employer breaches
• Maintain professionalism
• Preserve evidence
• Don't sign away rights

After resignation:

• File claim within limitation periods
• Gather all evidence
• Seek legal advice
• Pursue formal dispute resolution
• Consider mediation before litigation

What NOT to do:

• Don't resign impulsively without documentation
• Don't delay resignation too long after breach
• Don't continue without objecting
• Don't destroy evidence
• Don't make unfounded accusations

Employer strategies to prevent constructive dismissal claims

Proactive measures:

• Clear employment contracts
• Document all changes with employee agreement
• Fair and consistent policies
• Proper grievance procedures
• Regular communication with employees
• Training for managers
• Responsive HR function

When making changes:

• Consult with employee in advance
• Provide written notice of changes
• Explain business rationale
• Seek agreement rather than impose
• Consider alternatives
• Document discussions
• Allow reasonable adjustment time

Responding to concerns:

• Take complaints seriously
• Investigate promptly and thoroughly
• Document all steps taken
• Communicate outcomes
• Take corrective action when needed
• Follow up to ensure resolution

Managing difficult employees:

• Use proper performance management
• Document performance issues clearly
• Provide support and opportunities to improve
• Follow fair procedures
• Don't create intolerable conditions
• Consider alternatives to forced resignation

Legal framework and remedies

Available remedies vary by country:

Compensation:

• Payment in lieu of notice
• Severance pay equivalent
• Damages for loss of income
• Compensation for manner of dismissal
• Benefits lost

Reinstatement:

• Return to original position
• Less common remedy
• Only if relationship salvageable
• Court or tribunal ordered

Other remedies:

• Back pay for period since resignation
• Reference letter correction
• Declaration of rights
• Costs/legal fees
• Emotional distress damages (some jurisdictions)

Limitation periods:

• Must file claims within specified timeframes
• Typically 3-12 months from resignation
• Varies significantly by country
• Don't delay asserting rights

Cost and risk considerations

For employees:

• Legal costs of pursuing claim
• Time and stress of dispute
• Risk of losing claim
• Potential damage to reputation
• Loss of income during dispute
• Uncertain outcome

For employers:

• Legal defense costs
• Potential compensation payments
• Reputational damage
• Management time
• Employee morale impact
• Precedent for other employees

Alternative dispute resolution

Mediation:

• Neutral third party facilitates
• Voluntary and confidential
• Faster and less costly than litigation
• Creative settlement options
• Preserves relationships
• High success rate

Conciliation:

• Government agencies often provide
• Labor department or ministry involvement
• Free or low cost
• Informal process
• Many disputes resolved at this stage

Arbitration:

• Binding decision by arbitrator
• Faster than court
• Less formal procedures
• Costs shared or allocated
• Final and enforceable

Litigation as last resort:

• Court or tribunal proceedings
• Formal, lengthy process
• Higher costs
• Public record
• Win/lose outcome
• Appeals possible

How EOR providers help prevent constructive dismissal

When using AYP:

• Ensures compliant employment contracts
• Advises on proper change management
• Implements fair HR policies and procedures
• Manages employment changes professionally
• Provides grievance mechanisms
• Handles difficult situations properly
• Documents all actions appropriately
• Reduces risk of forced resignation scenarios

If claim arises:

• Assists with investigation
• Provides documentation
• Engages legal support
• Facilitates resolution
• Represents employer interests
• Manages dispute process

Best practices summary

For employers:

• Treat employees fairly and respectfully
• Honor employment contracts
• Make changes through proper process
• Respond to concerns promptly
• Document everything
• Seek agreement not imposition
• Provide safe, respectful workplace
• Train managers properly

For employees:

• Know your rights
• Document issues contemporaneously
• Raise concerns formally
• Allow employer chance to remedy
• Seek advice before resigning
• Preserve evidence
• Act within limitation periods
• Consider all options

Red flags for employers:

Warning signs employee may claim constructive dismissal:

• Formal grievances about working conditions
• Requests for contract terms in writing
• Objections to proposed changes
• Documentation of incidents
• Legal inquiries or advisor involvement
• Stress leave or medical issues
• Resignation letter citing specific breaches

‍